Responses to Violence

Counter-Violence

Responding to Violence with Violence

Counter-Violence

Responding to Violence with Violence

Take the offensive to achieve power/control to stop the violence. The assumption is that the only way violence will end is if a “better force” (usually ourselves”) uses more violence to overpower the other and end it.

Avoidance

  • Look the other way.

  • Deny it exists.

  • Pawn it off on someone else (police, military, others)

  • Don’t get involved

  • “Not my problem”

  • Feel powerless / don’t know what to do

 

Accommodation

  • Get used to it

  • Accept it as unavoidable/necessary

  • Think “I can’t change the system”

  • Adapt to it

  • Minimize it

  • Normalize it

  • Think “It’s not so bad”

This is especially true of cultural/structural violence which is not simply saying “Why can’t we all get along?” It’s a step-by-step process of transforming our attitudes, and grasping the complexity of structural violence and avoiding the pitfalls of moving too fast or too slow.

Nonviolence - the Third Way

  • Neither fight nor flight

  • The “way out of no way”

  • We often talk about taking the low road or the high road

  • The “low road” is the more traveled by; the easier one but one that leads to continued conflict

  • The “high road” is often seen as passive (accommodating)

What Within My Own Soul Holds Me Back from Taking a Stand?

Ken Butigan’s article “The Journey from Indifference to Heart-Unity in the Struggle Against Structural Violence” lays out 6 phases of the journey of transformation: (1) Indifference, (2) Distance, (3) Inclusion, (4) Awareness, (5) Allyship, (6) Heart-Unity.

Hand Gestures

Avoiding Violence

Accommodating Violence

Counter-violence

Hands over your eyes or ears

Arms extended in front of you, with palms up

Arms out with the hands up, as if pushing someone